OK, maybe I should call this blog Postus Voluminous...this is much longer than I ever dreamed it would be. My real friends will still read the whole thing, though.
This post is something that has been stirring in my mind for a few years now, since well before I had a blog where I could publish it. Before I give you my list, here are a few points of preface:
The 1990s began in 1991 and ended in 2000, based on the same principle that dictated that the first year of our new millennium was 2001, not 2000. (That principle is the nonexistence of the year 0 A.D.) I'm sorry if you can't grasp this. It is true anyway, and thus I will not be including any album released in 1990, but I reserve the right to include those released in 2000. Readers who don't like it are advised to start their own blogs.
Terminology: I tend to use "album," "record," and "CD" interchangeably. It's the result of being raised by the LP generation, working in a record store, and owning hundreds of compact discs, respectively. I hope you won't find that too confusing.
This is not intended to be objective. I'm not necessarily saying these ten albums are indisputably the best of the decade. These are the recordings that affected
me during the '90s, the ones that (if you'll spare me) provided the soundtrack of my life during high school and college. Unless you think my opinions are always necessarily objectively true...well, never mind. No one thinks that.
That said, I enjoy bantering about this stuff, so please include your additions and subtractions in the comments. I want to hear what you think!
The links on the album names will take you to the very helpful
All Music Guide. The best music reference in print is also the best music reference online.
The albums are listed in chronological order, in a blatant copout by the author to avoid the decision about which is the best and the subsequent complaining in the comments about said decision.
I decided to narrow this to rock music. It was too hard to narrow it to ten if I included jazz, hip-hop, and r&b. If I've still got any strength left at the end, maybe I'll add a few non-rock CDs that tried to make the list.
And finally, if you're interested in buying any of these albums in any format (including MP3), I'd really appreciate it if you'd
click this link to buy them from Amazon
. Help keep this blog free! Uh... or something like that.
Enough with that, on to the list!
1.
"Ten" (Pearl Jam)Released August 27, 1991.
Pearl Jam is the king of the alternative rock hill, the last band left standing after the genre fell apart toward the end of the decade.
Ten is their defining work, still their most complete, consistent album of the three that mattered in the decade. If not for one incredibly goofy song (pellet gun, anyone?), their sophomore effort
Vs. (née
5 Against the World) might have made this list instead. And
Vitalogy has a few moments of absolute brilliance, the best stuff Pearl Jam ever laid down in my opinion, but it is plagued by some weird filler that disqualifies it from my top ten. It was
Ten that sent Pearl Jam and so-called alternative music toward the mainstream, and I listened to it all through my high school years.
2.
"Nevermind" (Nirvana)Released September 24, 1991.
First, don't ask me about how I can put Nirvana in my list and not The Pixies, since Nirvana was so influenced by The Pixies. Well, I'll tell you why: I have never listened to The Pixies, and most people have never heard of The Pixies. But I listened to this Nirvana record non-stop, and everyone knows it.
Many people are too young or too old to recognize how Nirvana gave a generation its voice, and they consider the band's legacy inflated by Kurt Cobain's dramatic suicide. But those of us who were the right age in 1991 and 1992 know that this music moved us somehow in a way other music did not. (By the way, I think it is patently absurd that the idiots at
Rolling Stone named Kurt Cobain #12 on their list of the 100 greatest guitarists.)
3.
"Achtung Baby" (U2)Released November 19, 1991.
U2 is a juggernaut; they have to make this list. Since
Pop and
Zooropa never happened, there's really not much competition in this decade.
Achtung may very well be U2's finest effort ever, so it is an easy choice anyway. There is not one weak track on this CD, and there are a handful of real gems. The song "One" is among the most haunting, gorgeous songs recorded during my lifetime. Of all the albums on this list,
Achtung is the most obvious all-time classic. Whereas some of the others are very niche-y, this one is straight ahead great rock and roll music.
* * * * *
Interstitial: Show me three records released four months apart that are as good as these three, and I will bake you a cake. With your choice of frosting color.
* * * * *
4.
"Siamese Dream" (Smashing Pumpkins)Released July 27, 1993.
I've actually written about this CD
before.
Siamese Dream is eerily memorable but never familiar. It has one of the most complete song lineups of any alternative rock album. The diversity of compositions gives it a great whole-album feel that I soaked in deeply during my high school years. The thick layers of guitar crunch Billy Corgan pulled off in the studio are impressive, and Jimmy Chamberlain is easily the best drummer from the alternative rock era. Even Corgan's breathy whine-song grew on me quickly and seems to fit perfectly with everything else that's happening on the record. The Smashing Pumpkins are the third (and too often neglected) component of the alt-rock trifecta that shaped the genre's sound and mood during the early '90s, and this is their best effort.
5.
"Cure for Pain" (Morphine)Released September 14, 1993.
The most eclectic record in my list,
Cure For Pain is full of slide bass, smoky barroom vocals, tight drumbeats, and throaty baritone saxophone tones. As a saxophone player, I was drawn to anything that had horns or a jazz influence, and Morphine was overflowing with both. I instantly fell in love with this CD, and I call it up on my iPod right now and still be able to sing along with every word—not to mention hum along every sax solo. If you've never listened to Morphine, you owe it to yourself to check it out. It's like Thai food: you may not like it, but if you never try it, you're missing out on a whole world of unique flavor.
6.
"Under the Table and Dreaming" (Dave Matthews Band)Released September 29, 1994.
I admit it: I was a DMB freak for about five years. My gut wanted to include
Remember Two Things, which is mostly live and for many years was my favorite DMB record. My selection of
Under the Table instead is indicative of the fact that I appreciate music in a different way now than I did when I first started to like this group. Listening to this record today, I love the production Steve Lillywhite contributed to the band's approach. This album
sounds fantastic. The song selection includes some that feature the complex Dave Matthews guitar riffs ("Rhyme and Reason," "Warehouse"), some with anthemic singability ("Ants Marching"), and at least one perfect ballad ("Lover Lay Down").
Remember Two Things is a great raw live set, but it is not as good an album.
Under the Table has no weak filler; it's good from front to back.
Incidentally, what does it say about a band when its best release was a few years after its formation but over a decade ago?
7.
"Tomorrow the Green Grass" (The Jayhawks)Released February 14, 1995.
Twangy, harmonious, bluesy, catchy, clever and rootsy. I love this album. It has some of the best writing of the decade, and it's just so singable. Think of a blend of the Allman Brothers, the Indigo Girls, and, um, I don't know...Everclear. Great stuff that pretty much flew under the radar, with only the heartbreak ballad "Blue" getting any radio play, and that only on eclectic rock stations. It's definitely worth a listen if you're not familiar.
8.
"The Bends" (Radiohead)Released April 4, 1995.
Okay, I have a confession to make. I never listened to this record during the '90s. I just never got into Radiohead. Still,
The Bends is as arresting an album as any I have ever heard, so I can't resist including it in this list—even though it had no effect on me at the time. The guitar tone is heart-stopping; the vocals are dead-on to the feel of the record; the lyrics are offbeat and odd but not zany. It is another one of those CDs that can and should be listened to from start to finish, as one whole piece of work. And a brilliant piece of work it is.
9.
"The Story of the Ghost" (Phish)Released October 27, 1998.
Since I listen to so much Phish, there was never any question about the band making an appearance in this list. I couldn't quite decide between this one and the really wonderful 2000 release
Farmhouse, as the two are somewhat similar in approach. Both albums reflect the late-era Phish approach to the studio, which was to write shorter, simpler songs that can easily be expanded live. Of the two,
Farmhouse is the more mature offering, in my opinion; in the end, however, it was
Ghost that captured me more completely. The final six tracks flow together almost seamlessly in a gorgeous layer of meandering dream-funk. Although it was panned by critics (even more than usual for Phish), this might be my favorite recording of Phish's two-decade-plus career.
10.
"Parachutes" (Coldplay)Released July 10, 2000 (here's where all that braggadocio about there not being a year 0 A.D. pays off).
The highest praise I can give this CD is this: I kept putting it back in my car CD player. It would stay in the rotation for a month at a time for about three years. I never got sick of it. I'm still not sick of it. I really, really like it. Certain readers will undoubtedly want to flay me for including this record, and not because of its release date, either. There is an anti-Coldplay sentiment among thinking rock and roll fans, and I'm not sure why. It's great Brit pop-rock, start to finish. Catchy tunes, pop hooks, nice guitar riffs with pretty tone, airy falsettos. Good stuff.
* * * * * * * * *
Here are three other CDs that were equally important to my experience of the '90s. I kept them off the list because they're not rock albums. But they are all truly fantastic, and worth a listen if you ever get the chance.
1.
"Life on Planet Groove" (Maceo Parker)Released October 20, 1992. Horns, horns, horns. Funky. Listen for the one white guy in the audience. (He's the one who yells out, "All right!!!" at the end of a song.)
2.
"The Miseducation Of Lauryn Hill" (Lauryn Hill)Released August 25, 1998. Killer voice, killer writing, killer production. It's surprising, then, that she won five Grammys for this—they usually only give Grammys for crappy music.
3.
"Black Star" (Black Star, Mos Def, Talib Kweli)Also released August 25, 1998. A good day for positive hip-hop, apparently. This is the best rap album I've ever heard.
Wow. If you're still reading at this point, you win a cake. But no colored frosting.