While we were in South Carolina, we did one of those multi-date birthday parties that families separated by great distances often do. So even though it was three weeks after my birthday, I got a present. That was pretty cool. My parents were nice enough to buy me the
new mouse Apple is selling. (I refuse to mention its goofy name, just as I refuse to mention the goofy name of their
hot new iPod. Both are great new products, but the names are lousy.)
This is the perfect sort of thing to get as a gift. It's a little overpriced, enough that you can't really justify buying it for yourself, but it's a special little thing that makes sense to buy for someone else. Or in my case, to have someone else buy for you:
Yes, this is my Elated Face.What makes this mouse unique? Two big things. First, it's the only mouse Apple has ever made with multi-button capability. Apple has always used single-button mice, insisting that human interface studies have shown split-button and multi-button mice don't have a net benefit to users. There are in fact studies that demonstrate this, but the reality is that most experienced computer users still want to right-click and scroll and such. This mouse not only allows a right-click, but it also has buttons on the side that you can squeeze to get additional functionality. Second and more importantly, it has a scroll ball, not a wheel but a
ball that allows you to scroll horizontally and diagonally as well as vertically.
I'll talk about these in reverse order. First the scroll ball, which I'm very excited about. I love it. If you ever work with large photos, you can imagine how nice it would be to be able to use your mouse scroll horizontally or diagonally to get from one part of the image to another. It's also great to use in applications that have timelines or other horizontal fields. I use it all the time this way in iPhoto, which in "Edit" mode arranges photo thumbnails horizontally above the enlarged image you're working with. The ball has a gentle traction and a soft buzzy-clicky sort of sound, making it pleasant to use and nicely responsive. It is quite small and is set into the body of the mouse, so you can use it by barely lifting a finger. If I had to guess, I would say you'll see a lot of scroll balls appearing on generic mice soon.
The multi-button functionality is not as much of a home run as the scroll ball, but it is still nice. What is most noticeable about it is the fact that the body of the mouse is not split in the middle like a traditional two-button mouse. It is one solid piece, but there are sensors under the mouse housing that detect if you're clicking with the right side or the left side. Like other Apple mice, the whole body of the mouse clicks down, not just a button.
This takes some getting used to, but I have come to appreciate it. It changes the way you hold and click the mouse. I end up holding it a little farther back, using my wrist a little more and my fingers a little less. It seems like a slightly calmer, gentler way to use the mouse. I know that sounds goofy, but it's true.
A great deal of complaining has followed the announcement of this mouse because of one apparent flaw: if you are holding both fingers on the mouse and press down on the right side, it won't right-click. The sensors don't work unless you lift your index finger off the left-click area when you press the mouse down. Indeed, this is annoying, especially at first, and especially if you expect this mouse to work exactly like a regular two-button mouse. As I just noted, however, it doesn't seem as if you're supposed to expect that out of a mouse that clicks the way Apple mice do.
It took all of five minutes to get my hand trained to make the slightly different action required to right-click. This might be a deal-breaker for some people, but it isn't for me. It's certainly far less annoying than some cheap two-button mice that are made so you accidentally click the right-click when you don't want to click at all.
As for the squeeze buttons, I think they're basically useless. It's difficult to press with the proper amount of pressure. What seems right isn't quite enough, and if you squeeze too hard, it responds as if you squeezed them twice. Since they're intended to work with Dashboard or Exposé, this is counterproductive. I wish they worked independently of each other and could be programmed to go Back and Forward in a browser.
All in all, I am very happy with the new mouse, except for one thing. I mostly use my PowerBook, and since we plugged the new mouse into the desktop Mac, Tracey gets to have most of the fun with my birthday present.